Sincere, and Real

Is being sincere the same as being real?

Original

Mencius 4A·12誠者，天之道也；思誠者，人之道也。至誠而不動者，未之有也；不誠，未有能動者也。The Mean, ch. 20誠者，天之道也；誠之者，人之道也。……誠之者，擇善而固執之者也。Commentary on Qian (Wenyan)閑邪存其誠。……修辭立其誠，所以居業也。Zhuangzi 6 · The Great Teacher且有真人而後有真知。……古之真人，其寢不夢，其覺無憂。

In plain words

Sincerity is the way of Heaven; to seek sincerity is the way of humans. No one fully sincere has ever failed to move others; no one insincere has ever moved anyone.

Sincerity is the way of Heaven; making oneself sincere is the way of humans. … To make oneself sincere is to choose the good and hold on to it firmly.

Bar the crooked, and keep sincerity within. … Craft your words and stand them on sincerity: that is how one's work is made to last.

First there is a real person; then there is real knowing. … The real people of old slept without dreams and woke without worry.

Key words

誠chéngTrue, with nothing false; for Confucians, honest with yourself and with others.
真zhēnDaoist realness: what you are by nature, without pose or performance.
擇善固執zé shàn gù zhíChoose the good and hold it fast: the Mean's definition of making oneself sincere.

Reading it step by step

This page opens our second theme: the work of being human. The first theme asked why: why be good at all, what Heaven is, where fate and human nature come from. This one asks how: how a person lives those answers out, day by day. The first step is sincerity.

Confucians say 诚, sincere. Daoists say 真, real. The two words often travel together, but they come from different roads.

First: Mencius says Heaven has only one version, so only people need to seek sincerity. "Sincerity is the way of Heaven." The seasons turn and flowers fall, and none of it is pretending; a cat never tries to bark. Nature can't be insincere, because it doesn't have to choose. People do. We weigh gain and loss, so we alone can say what we don't mean. That's why Mencius adds: "To seek sincerity is the way of humans." This is not sitting and pondering. It is turning back and wanting to be true. And he makes a promise: no one fully sincere has failed to move others, and no one insincere has ever moved anyone.

Second: the Mean and the Commentary make sincerity a road, not a mood. The Doctrine of the Mean rewrites Mencius' phrase as "making oneself sincere," then defines it: choose the good and hold on to it. First tell what is worth doing; then don't let go. The Commentary on the Changes brings the work down to daily words and deeds. "Bar the crooked and keep sincerity within": like bolting a gate, so what's inside stays safe. "Craft your words and stand them on sincerity": being true also takes care in how you say things. Blurting something hurtful and calling it honesty is not sincerity. It's a lack of practice.

Third: Zhuangzi says first a real person, then real knowing. Zhuangzi rarely says 诚; he says 真. His real person "sleeps without dreams and wakes without worry." This realness is less a duty to others than a return to what you were given by the Dao: not acting, not straining. Confucian sincerity lets you stand firm among people. Daoist realness lets you set things down amid gain and loss, and sleep. One faces outward, one inward. Both refuse to perform.

Heaven's way

sincereonly one version; never pretends

Mencius · the Mean

the human way

seek it · make itchoose the good, bar the crooked, craft your words

Mencius · Mean · Commentary

the real person

realback to what you are; no acting, no straining

Zhuangzi

Sincerity steadies you among people; realness lets you set things down.

Today it might look like this. You send your manager a polished email full of commitment, and your heart isn't in it: that isn't sincere. You drop a blunt objection into the group chat and embarrass a colleague: that isn't sincere either. Ask first what you really think, then spend ten minutes shaping it so it can be heard. And at night, when the light goes off, if you don't have to replay the day's role in your head, that is a little of the real.

Sincerity is chosen daily. The real is something you return to.

One line to carry

Sincerity is chosen daily; the real is where you return.

Today's question

When did you last say something polished that you didn't mean? If you could say it again, how would you make it both sincere and easy to hear?

Quick check

Mencius says sincerity is Heaven's way. Why do people still need to seek it?

Next pageWhen No One Is WatchingPage 6

II · The Work of Being Human — Sincerity, being alone, ritual, profit and rightness, how far love reaches

Printable journal pages · Threads · About

Sister site: 五十策 Fifty Stalks